Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Roads to Rome (moovellab.com)
32 points by mbostock on Dec 11, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 9 comments


There are some interesting oddnesses here:

Vatican can't really "experience huge spatial growth" from this experiment. It is surrounded by Rome. Traffic from any origin point will reach Rome before it reaches The Holy See. I understand that this has probably happened because the calculation is to a specific "centre of the city" point, which means that any traffic entering Rome from the Westish will hit Vatican first.

Looking at the interactive map is fun.

For some reason, it's faster to get to Paris from Hemel Hempstead that it is to get to London. And the opposite is true of Pont-l'Évêque. I originally wondered if this was calculated using active traffic data, and a couple of particularly bad traffic jams might have skewed the results.

But then I looked for others: Montreuil to Brussels is very odd, as is the strange case of travellers from the Faroe Islands driving through Denmark, Germany and the Netherlands, before reaching their nearest capital in Brussels.

The oddest example of this is that travellers from half of Apulia find it quicker to drive straight past San Marino, Ljubljana and Zagreb, before reaching Sarajevo.


I think they have some bugs: it also claims it's faster to drive from Milwaukee, WI to Lansing, MI than the adjacent Madison, WI. Furthermore, there is a section of I90, a Madison ring road, which Google Maps claims is 15 minutes from Madison city center and 5+ hours from Lansing, while this map claims it's closer to Lansing. There are similar tendrils of I196 through Holland, MI and I to Grand Rapids, MI that go to Madison (5+ hours) instead of Lansing (1-2 hours).

Or maybe we're reading the map wrong? You can get to each capital any number of potentially shorter ways, but almost any location in Michigan routed to Madison will take 196, while only a few from that spot going Lansing will take that road...


See this issue for possible reasons https://github.com/graphhopper/graphhopper/issues/382


Great idea and pretty cool execution, with the only caveat that the interactive maps don't work on my FF browser, it shows a blank page. If anyone involved with the project sees this comment, I'm using Firefox version 41.0.2, on Mac OSX.


BTW: how are duplicates normally handled on hacker news? This - 5 dups for this - looks odd https://hn.algolia.com/?query=rome%20roads&type=story&sort=b...


I don't get this. Don't all roads lead to all non-isolated cities?


It is a famous idiom, hence the pun: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/all_roads_lead_to_Rome


I would take it a s a piece of art. The factual representation of the Italian saying "all roads lead to Rome".


Very cool maps indeed, would love to have this on my wall sometime.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: