I work for Wikimedia and I have been one of the few weirdos assisting in its creation back in the early 2000's. The first time I got exposed to wikis predates Wikipedia and my stance was:
- a site editable by anyone on the internet? That is never going to fly
Few months later I followed a link to Wikipedia and that clicked, we can definitely build an encyclopedia online and the hope (I was in my early 20's) or bet was that more people were wiling to write article than people willing to deface it. I guess we won that bet by a large margin :-]
Even if I was younger, I was not clueless. I was well aware some people would deface it and it did happen. I have also been involved in two very long and tedious fights with editors having a political agenda, which diverting me from actually writing articles. I think that is the real danger: shifting the focus of people from writing articles toward pointless long discussions.
That burning up of resources of the good guys is exactly why a lot of stuff eventually derails. Just like the fight against the online crime rings that hold people's data ransom and that deface and destroy: the defenders have to succeed all the time, the attackers only have to succeed part of the time to be successful. So over a long enough run the attackers have an edge. Wikipedia is an exception, so far. Enough people cherish it that they are willing to put in the effort. But the day enough of them blink at the same time the assholes will take over. I hope that day will never come, but I'm not sure it will not. On a human scale Wikipedia is still very young.
- a site editable by anyone on the internet? That is never going to fly
Few months later I followed a link to Wikipedia and that clicked, we can definitely build an encyclopedia online and the hope (I was in my early 20's) or bet was that more people were wiling to write article than people willing to deface it. I guess we won that bet by a large margin :-]
Even if I was younger, I was not clueless. I was well aware some people would deface it and it did happen. I have also been involved in two very long and tedious fights with editors having a political agenda, which diverting me from actually writing articles. I think that is the real danger: shifting the focus of people from writing articles toward pointless long discussions.