Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They don't explain how they fix even one of the problems they mention at the top. Maybe I'm missing something here but this is just pure marketing bleh.


It is marketing, yes. But it’s also announcing a brand new ecosystem that doesn’t exist yet so I’m not too surprised they don’t have in depth implementation details right now.

Marketing isn’t automatically evil. If you’re starting an open source project you want people to contribute to you’re going to want to market it.


I don’t think this ecosystem is new. Most of the projects they mention have been around 5+ years.

I think this is a new funding initiative though, and I wish them luck.


The first paragraph introduces the idea of a comprehensive initiative for an "all of the above" mobile ecosystem, listing out the key pieces of that ecosystem.

Then there's a lot of mission statement and vision statement type things that appear to be directed at a broad audience, But then specifically they say this:

>F-Droid will play a major role in this project, tasked with creating a decentralized distribution system for developers to deliver apps to Android users.

It feels like that's kind of what F-droid does already (sans decentralization, unless we regard the capability of custom repos as adequate to the task).

So I get the vision, I get the idea of it being under the umbrella of some broader project that's about other aspects of the mobile ecosystem such as operating systems, cloud services, and so on. I'm not sure what's different but I welcome the spirit of the initiative and I suppose that's the important thing.


I believe F-Droid is operating under a series of grants totaling €4.4 million for the next two years. This release is probably directed at the various groups funding them.

I hope they succeed but I wish they were using something other than Android. A by-Europeans-for-Europeans project shouldn't be based on an American OS IMHO.

https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/101135795


I thought the same but eventually I recognized the sound of the government wheelworks of bureaucracy. The article simply explains a single thing elaborately.


yes it had all the hallmarks of an seo campaign




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: