i ran a synapse instance for a couple years for private purposes, but at this point the ecosystem seems kinda captured by element. self hosting is a pain. in some places it's really hard to tell that mistakes in good faith were made or it's just intentionally complicated to keep "normal" people from running their own instance. Especially the whole worker setup was subject to change multiple times and broke my instance every. single. time. couple that with sparse, out of date documentation and the "pro edition" they now announced suddenly makes a lot of sense (from their perspective at least)
- They own Element, the by far most used client
- They own Synapse, the by far most used server
- They own dendrite, the only matrix server so far that even comes close to spec adherance with synapse, which has been strangled (as evidenced by the last release almost half a year ago [3])
Because everyone is running synapse, everyone needs to keep running synapse or risk losing compatibility with the federation.
This is not what the sales brochure for matrix read like. Like, at all.
Do y'all believe it's random chance that the official synapse docker-compose does not come with async workers? [1]
And now check out the terrible setup process for setting up the whole "workers magic" (which, mind you, is unavoidable the moment you have some bigger rooms joined) [2] - Like who on this godforsaken planet considers this valid even for 2022? Pair that with how easy to handle the base documentation is and things start to smell. They have the stench of trying to artificially create a moot by making it "too hard for non-pros".
I understand synapse and dendrite development need funding, but this is not the way to go. All good will towards Element as a steward of matrix I had is completely eroded by now and I assume that will be the case for many others too. Forks are bound to happen at this point and I'm looking forward to the ecosystem become more diverse again.
Oh, and did you know the Matrix Foundation is infact a UK based Inc. controlled by 5 people in 5 companies, of which 4 companies are residing at the same address [4] and the fifth has an odd interest in NFTs and other BS?
[2] https://matrix-org.github.io/synapse/latest/workers.html - note how this page is already marked as deprecated. Prepare for it to vanish altogether soon. You are not supposed to set up workers, you are supposed to beg element to run a decent matrix server
- They own Element, the by far most used client
- They own Synapse, the by far most used server
- They own dendrite, the only matrix server so far that even comes close to spec adherance with synapse, which has been strangled (as evidenced by the last release almost half a year ago [3])
Because everyone is running synapse, everyone needs to keep running synapse or risk losing compatibility with the federation.
This is not what the sales brochure for matrix read like. Like, at all.
Do y'all believe it's random chance that the official synapse docker-compose does not come with async workers? [1]
And now check out the terrible setup process for setting up the whole "workers magic" (which, mind you, is unavoidable the moment you have some bigger rooms joined) [2] - Like who on this godforsaken planet considers this valid even for 2022? Pair that with how easy to handle the base documentation is and things start to smell. They have the stench of trying to artificially create a moot by making it "too hard for non-pros".
I understand synapse and dendrite development need funding, but this is not the way to go. All good will towards Element as a steward of matrix I had is completely eroded by now and I assume that will be the case for many others too. Forks are bound to happen at this point and I'm looking forward to the ecosystem become more diverse again.
Oh, and did you know the Matrix Foundation is infact a UK based Inc. controlled by 5 people in 5 companies, of which 4 companies are residing at the same address [4] and the fifth has an odd interest in NFTs and other BS?
[1] https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/blob/develop/contrib/d...
[2] https://matrix-org.github.io/synapse/latest/workers.html - note how this page is already marked as deprecated. Prepare for it to vanish altogether soon. You are not supposed to set up workers, you are supposed to beg element to run a decent matrix server
[3] https://github.com/matrix-org/dendrite
[4] https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/c...