Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It depends on your citizenship. Some European countries reject 50% Indian Schengen visa applicantions.

https://www.cntraveller.in/story/these-3-countries-rejected-...



Schengen is different from EU.

More importantly, and according to your link, only Estonia rejected 50+% Indian applications, everyone else rejected less than 50%, with only 2 others anywhere near 50% (Malta and Slovenia).

So out of 29 countries in the Schengen area only 3 were anywhere near the 50% mark and all 3 are tiny countries as far as both area and populations are concerned (those 3 combined account for only 4 million people in total).

Also, just to take one of those 3, Estonia has an overall high rejection rate in comparison to all the others, and that started happening after the pandemic.

Details are important


> Schengen is different from EU.

Schengen isn't "different from EU". It originally was separate from EU, but since 1999 has been an aspect of the EU. Per Wikipedia:

> Originally, the Schengen treaties and the rules adopted under them operated independently from the European Union. However, in 1999 they were incorporated into European Union law by the Amsterdam Treaty, while providing opt-outs for the only two EU member states that had remained outside the Area: Ireland and the United Kingdom (which subsequently withdrew from the EU in 2020). Schengen is now a core part of EU law, and all EU member states without an opt-out which have not already joined the Schengen Area are legally obliged to do so when technical requirements have been met. Several non-EU countries are included in the area through special association agreements.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Agreement


please read the text you quoted:

"Several non-EU countries are included in the area through special association agreements."


Yes, but the inclusion of a non-EU country in an EU programme as a special exception (not unique to Schengen) doesn’t thereby make it a non-EU programme, which is a natural interpretation of what you said


I never wrote that Schengen "is not an EU programme", I pointed out succintly that the countries in Schengen and the countries in EU are not the same thing.

In fact there are also EU countries NOT in Schengen. And there are countries in Europe but not in the EU which are not in Schengen either.


At least they don’t issue you a visa and then arbitrarily detain you at the border.

Obtaining a work visa in a particular country is not a human right, and their issuance are up to the hosting country’s policies.


> work visa

I would guess that 90% of the applications were for travel, not work.

> their issuance are up to the hosting country’s policies

These countries don't even bother to apply their policies. Some cases I heard about indicate that they randomly reject applications, without reviewing them.


Ah, you’re right. The linked article doesn’t say, but apparently a Schengen Visa is “for short-term purposes, such as tourism or business trips. Work permits are apparently not counted in these numbers, then.

As to whether they are conforming tot heir own policies or not, I can’t find any evidence either way in the linked article. They’re just stating the numbers.


>Estonia, Malta and Slovenia rejected the highest percentage of Schengen visa applications from India last year, while Germany, Italy and Hungary were most accommodating.

Sounds like Estonia, Malta, and Slovenia didn't want their countries to become transits for illegal immigration from India to the UK.

Countries like Germany get legitimate Indian immigration for work and higher education so their rejection rate is lower.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: