Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Gotta love regulation stifling the living daylights our of your society.


Or: Gotta love regulation keeping our societies alive.

The US averages 14.9/100k traffic fatalities, Europe 6.7 [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...


Canada beats the euro average at 4.7 but similarly allows regular Joe’s to drive a moving truck and trailer a car behind it with a general license.

+ Canada’s rates are better on a per km basis (even beating the Dutch).

Annual/biannual safety inspections are only required in 3 of 10 provinces and those 3 are on the smaller side (PEI, NS and NB).

Motor vehicle infraction enforcement is… an afterthought for Canadian police (they don’t think/care that their salary/town depends on it). But admittedly, even lighter than I’ve experienced in Europe.

It’s gotta be some other factor behind excess US road fatalities.


I think the majority of Canada's GWVR limits can be a factor; i.e. outside of Ontario it's less than half what the US limit is for a standard license.

I think also the lower number of lanes on routes like the 401 help, usually[0].

Even though it's been a while, every drive in Canada just felt more leisurely. Speed limits in general are lower, there's more stop signs where they should be.

[0] - Except when a whiskey truck tips over and it's now a 2 hour delay to the next exit...


American drivers are also entitled assholes (I say as an American driver). How DARE you tell me I can't do what I want, when I want, or change my behavior in the slightest to benefit my society/local community?


God forbid a commuter wants to do the speed limit in the righthand lane without being tailgated!


> the righthand lane

sadly, that's very often the passing lane


It gets complicated depending on the highway, at least around me.

Heck even some of the non highway roads.

Cause I'm in MI, where we have Michigan lefts, and somewhere between surges of out-of-state transplants and COVID everyone has lost the plot on...

But overall around here, we have lots of 3/4 lane highways.

From left to right on a 4 lane...

Left lane is prettymuch always fastest traffic, with a occasional trucker stupidity around failing to not use the leftmost lane unless part of the actual route.

Next lane on a 4 lane is more faster traffic, possibly more trucker stupidity because typically they are supposed to be in the right two lanes unless there is a split incoming where they have to go left.

Next lane on a 4 lane is all of the wimpy trucks and the freight drivers following state law (i.e. we often have a higher speed limit for 'not-truck' than 'truck')

Last lane, is entering/exiting traffic; may go faster than prior lane at times but is more likely to have slowdowns from people who had at least a quarter mile to see what traffic was and attempt to match speed...

On a 3 lane, it's similar, except trucks in general will stay in the middle or right, but usually the middle.

---

Where it gets ugly though, is that my state is Michigan, so we have 'Michigan Lefts'.

i.e. on many roads, to do a left turn you take an intentional turn-around through a median, then take a right back at the intersection.

This normally works but sometimes it means for such roads that the left lane is not in fact the fastest lane overall.


[flagged]


If you think Canada of all places doesn't have immigrants driving around, boy do I have news for you.


Immigrants lower the local crime rates.


Yes! The migrants fleeing to the US with nothing but the shirt on their back and tens of thousands of dollars in their pocket so they can buy an F350 Superduty and run over kids with it.


They're not buying the commercial tractor-trailers they're just operating them with CDLs California issued to them without even having enough basic English knowledge to read road signs, with predictable results.

Of course this is partially a problem of the government creating the problem of disqualifying Californians who could perform the job. Like 40% of California smokes weed but recreational use disqualifies you from a DOT physical for interstate CDL driving eligibility, and probably medical too though for not much longer since it's now schedule III and the DOT just hasn't caught up with the rescheduling yet.


Do you have proof of any of that?


  An investigation by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration found significant failures by California, Washington, and New Mexico to properly place drivers out-of-service for ELP violations. In addition to the data, California Highway Patrol has also publicly stated it has no intention of following this important federal regulation.   

  California – California has failed to adopt and enforce compatible ELP laws and regulations. From June 25, 2025 through August 21, 2025, of the roughly 34,000 inspections resulting in at least one reported violation, only one inspection involved an ELP violation resulting in a driver being placed out of service. Notably, at least 23 drivers with documented ELP out-of-service violations in other states were later inspected in California – yet the state failed to honor those violations or enforce ELP, allowing unqualified drivers to continue operating on our roads.

https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/trumps-transpor...


Nothing better than being alive! We should ban all forms of transportation that aren't walking, which will be heavily permitted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: